I loved the tilla in pics and had thought it would make a great extra cover (if Graco sells it that way), but did not like it in person. I was disappointed that after taking out the insert (that most of us won't be using), there is little purple on it. I like colors, but I know that's not true for everyone. However, I also found the textured fabric too rough. I am not a fan of textured weaves on car seats. I thought it was fairly light in color too.
The daisy is not a plush fabric, but it is very smooth and not at all rough. The solid color is a soft sueded fabric and ours is holding up great so far. But it is bright and too over the top for some. I like fun seat covers. After all, they grow up so fast..