I'd say a Marathon on sale like a PP stated. The seat rear faces to 35 and forward faces to 65 pounds. It has build in lock offs and no twist straps which are nice. Also very cute covers if that matters
Otherwise the Evenflo Triumph Advance will last you probably as long since you don't need the extra 15 lbs the Marathon offers with your little one and they have the same harness heights basically. The EFTA goes to 50 lbs forward facing. It has a "different" way to tighten the harness so I'd make sure you like it first if possible. Most Targets and Walmarts carry it for you to try. Some love it and some hate it. It also has straps that move up and down as your child grows very easily. You never have to rethread them.
It can be found for about $120-$150. Otherwise, the Learning Curve True Fit that goes to 65 lbs (and 35 rear facing) is a tad more expensive but is very easy to use. It has built in lock offs and you never have to rethread the straps to change the harness height like most seats. They just move up and down. It can be up to about $180
The Safety 1st Avenue/Uptown is also a very good economical seat. It has high harness heights. While it only goes to 40 lbs, it should get most kids pretty close to 40 lbs vs other 40 seats that can be outgrown around 18 months-2years. It is very comfy. However, rear facing adjusting the harness tightness can be very difficult. The adjuster is so low it's hard to get at sometimes. This seat is around $90.