Is this cargo barrier safe? Or alternatives, please?

trinalb · Oct 18, 2012

I have been trying to convince DH that we need to secure items in our car in case of an accident. He thinks I'm crazy! Comprehensive links supporting this would be great...

The reason for this post, though, is that I want a barrier to prevent cargo from flying around the vehicle in an accident. I've found this on a local auction for an amazing deal and wonder if it's a good, safe option. It is apparently pressure mounted, adjusted by wing nuts:

F573BFB3-AA8B-4093-9845-25B30AA08CAF-24523-000018D749B0FEF1.jpg

If this isn't a good option, why? Is there such a thing as a very budget friendly barrier that is safe and installs/uninstalls in one quick, easy step? I don't think DH will go for it if it's complicated, time-consuming, expensive, or takes up much cargo room.

Oh, we have a 2001 Nissan Pathfinder but are considering getting a minivan or truck in the near future instead.

canadiangie · Oct 18, 2012

It too will likely fly in a crash -- like as soon as your cargo slams into it, or the frame of the vehicle shifts at all. Then you've got the barrier flying into your occupant space, and your cargo is following right behind it.

The only truly secure option is one that is installed. As in bolts to frame.

Or you can secure your cargo to the cargo hooks in your cargo area...

I use an old tether strap; one end is attached to a cargo hook, then I loop the strap through the frame of my stroller, and then clip the tether hook back onto the cargo hook. And I only have a stroller in the vehicle if i know im going to need it. Groceries get packed forward towards the back of the 2nd row. Heavy items get put on the floor of the front seat. When we travel I pack everything in laundry baskets instead of heavy suitcases. It's not a perfect system, but I'm trying. I can't have my dealership install a barrier because I need access to my 3rd row (it's usually folded flat, but not always).

trinalb · Oct 18, 2012

Are those cargo hooks actually capable if holding heavy weights? They look so flimsy! I don't think DH would go for a permanently installed cage. He is already unhappy about using something that can be removed. And don't the cages obstruct your view?