I have been having a FB chat with a friend about the allowable handle position on a bucket. She said I could C&P this here for more opinions.
She asked about seeing buckets with the handle up and how to approach someone and tell them that that is wrong.
(me)Many carseat you can have it all the way up or all the way down just not the middle positions.
(her)from what I know your not supposed to have it up at all because of the way it will impact with the back of the seat in a collision
(me)It was that way for a long time, but most of the manufactures have changed it to all the way up or all the way down. The handle used to not be reinforced so it would splinter and sent plastic shards everywhere, but now it is supposedly better.
(her)from the videos I watched the reason it should not be up is because of the way it jars the seat
(Me)what videos?
(her)the videos we had to watch to get ds out of the hospital
(me)the changes have all been in the last couple of years
and the videos might have been a bit out of date
(her)but...if it is just reinforced then it would jar against the seat more wouldnt it?
(me)I had learned that it was because of plastic handle shattering, I have never heard of it "jarring" the seat
if you have a good install, the handle should not jar the seat. the seat should tip towards the vehicle seat back and "cocoon" the baby in a crash
(her)yeah that's what I mean
if the handle is down (in the carry position) it will hit the back of the seat, instead of the seat moving to cradle the baby
the videos showed that the seat should tilt forward toward the back of the seat when rear facing. but the handle would stop the tilting motion short.
I am wondering if the handle should be down even with a new seat.
(Me)I understand what you are saying. I will try and find a better explanation for you of why they say it is ok now
So anyone have a better explanation for her?
She asked about seeing buckets with the handle up and how to approach someone and tell them that that is wrong.
(me)Many carseat you can have it all the way up or all the way down just not the middle positions.
(her)from what I know your not supposed to have it up at all because of the way it will impact with the back of the seat in a collision
(me)It was that way for a long time, but most of the manufactures have changed it to all the way up or all the way down. The handle used to not be reinforced so it would splinter and sent plastic shards everywhere, but now it is supposedly better.
(her)from the videos I watched the reason it should not be up is because of the way it jars the seat
(Me)what videos?
(her)the videos we had to watch to get ds out of the hospital
(me)the changes have all been in the last couple of years
and the videos might have been a bit out of date
(her)but...if it is just reinforced then it would jar against the seat more wouldnt it?
(me)I had learned that it was because of plastic handle shattering, I have never heard of it "jarring" the seat
if you have a good install, the handle should not jar the seat. the seat should tip towards the vehicle seat back and "cocoon" the baby in a crash
(her)yeah that's what I mean
if the handle is down (in the carry position) it will hit the back of the seat, instead of the seat moving to cradle the baby
the videos showed that the seat should tilt forward toward the back of the seat when rear facing. but the handle would stop the tilting motion short.
I am wondering if the handle should be down even with a new seat.
(Me)I understand what you are saying. I will try and find a better explanation for you of why they say it is ok now
So anyone have a better explanation for her?